JustPaste.it

Discussion Board Forum 4

The author's argument

 

Goffart argues that the Romans and the German tribes were never in constant conflict with one another, but they occupied a shared space. The Roman Empire had grown weak owing to the split and internal rivalries between different outfits. As Goffart puts it, most Germans defeat by the Romans, but the survivors persuade them to shoulder Roman tasks (Goffart, 2008). For example, Visigoths settled as federate allies governed by their kings while serving Rome's military needs. At the end of the rivalry, they reward with a swath of territory called Aquitania. In essence, it was not all military incursion, and bloody face-off as most standard accounts provide but more of a coexistence approach where Romans drew Barbarians into military service to serve divergent interests of power.

 

How one might counter the argument

 

One might argue that cooperation was because Romans failed to dislodge Germans from their territory. The Romans used the Germanic tribes against one another, while the German tribes used these divisions to gain territory. However, the Romans largely failed to dislodge them through a series of invasions and conflicts that often ended up in draws. For example, the Visigoths, Burgundians, and the Franks fought Attila to a draw in the Mauriac plains in the battle for Aquitania (Ward, Heichelheim and Yeo, 2016). As a result, Flavius Aetius decided to take in the German tribes as federate allies instead of adversaries because they helped him fight his wars. In essence, German tribes valued the imperial titles' prestige and autonomy since they served at their discretion. 

 

References

 

Goffart, W. (2008). Rome's final conquest: The barbarians. History Compass, 6(3), 855-883. doi:10.1111/j.1478-0542.2008.00523.x

 

Ward, A. M., Heichelheim, F. M., & Yeo, C. A. (2016). History of the Roman people. Routledge.