Nectarine Traditional compo - Votes and comments

Song numbers:

01 - Serpent

02 - silok

03 - the_Deviant

04 - yzi

Phlubby_Gnome
01 - 5 stars, Slightly preferred to 04: 1* extra
02 - 3 stars
03 - 4 stars
04 - 4 stars, Could this be a late entry...

franz_opa
01 - 4 stars - a solo adds a lot to it
02 - 4 stars - tangerine dreamish or something, peaceful vibes
03 - 4 stars - a nice energetic song
04 - 5 stars - I guess some effort has gone into this

Arrakis

01: 4 stars; serpicos rulez: styled and sober proper and runner
02: 3 stars: the choirs are so traditionnal-like !
03: 5 stars: crazy burning metal traditionnal high trance celtic mix
04: 4 stars: Trad cool stuff not that scene related [NOTE: stars are rounded from 3,5 to 4]

the_Deviant
01 - 5 stars - Nice haunting lead, overall a nice rounded sound.
02 - 3 stars - Decent composition but just lacking a little something for me to completely fill out the sound.
03 - -
04 - 4 stars - Bit of a curveball, I feel like the acoustic brass sound is pushing the spirit of 'computer age remix' a little? Anyhow, great composition.

Vithor
01 - 4 "A good _traditional_ spirit, but it's quiet somehow.."
02 - 2 "A very monotonous chorus or did it just seem to me?"
03 - 3 "Some kind of upbeat folk theme?"
04 - 5 "Crazy blues'n jazz from Yzi!?"

mirrorbird
01 - 4 stars, "catchy, and my guess for Serpent"
02 - 3 stars, "very atmospheric, mostly because of instrument choice"
03 - 2 stars, "bassline a bit heavy and repetitive; sounds quite wrong at 2'10"
04 - 4 stars, "extremely stylish, fun choice of modern genre"

serpent
01 - Own one, no score
02 - 3 stars. Don't know the original, if it's not "Entre le bœuf et l'âne gris" (?) anyway, starts nicely, middle part is a bit messy and ends like starts.
03 - 3 stars. I feel i should know the original, but i don't. This is at least definitely modern [:)]
04 - 4 stars. Original is "Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star" (?) Good stuff as always.

yzi
01 - 4 stars, "the cleanest sounding and easiest to listen to"
02 - 3 stars, "ok"
03 - 3 stars, "ok but a bit muddy"

silok
01 - 4,"Nice chippie of von den elden from Serpent :)"
02 - 0,"no selfvoting"
03 - 3,"somehow fascinating, is it from Nerdn ?"
04 - 4,"Yzi jo, ive no idea what it is xD"

VodkaBot
01 - 3 stars
02 - 2 stars
03 - 4 stars (winner)
04 - 3 stars (good quality but a bit boring)

NerdN
01. Nice serpent tune. 4 stars
02. Calm stuff. 4 stars
03. Interesting. 4 stars
04. Yzi, excellent stuff, but not interesting. 3 stars.