Testimony of Sheikh Abu Abdel Aziz al-Qatari proving the deception of ISIS
Firstly I will translate what Adnani said about Sheikh al-Qatari giving him tazkiyah so no one has an excuse to claim that Sheikh al-Qatari is biased
Adnani said, giving tazkiyah to Sheikh Abu Abdel Aziz al-Qatari, in his statement 'This was never our manhaj':
"Oh Lord ask them why they didn’t mourn the death of Sheikh Abu Abdel Aziz al-Qatari (may Allah have mercy on him), why didn't they incite against his killers and demand justice for his blood? (Is it because) He spent his life moving between the (jihadi) fields and in prisons! Is it because it is proven Dawlah did not kill him? They know we didn’t kill him, would they have remained silent if they didn’t know who his killers were? Or would they have blamed Dawlah?" END Quote.
Ok so that was Adnani praising and giving tazkiyah to Sheikh al-Qatari after al-Qatari's martyrdom. Now let's see what Adnani said in his mubahala.
"Here I will recall some of it and I will make mubahala on it, so let him make mubahala with me if he is truthful. Oh you who believe (let us) place the Curse of Allah on the liar (between us). Oh Allah your servant Abu AbdAllah al-Shami claimed that we raised the matter (ISI expanding to Syria) to Sheikh Aymen al-Zawahiri WHERE BOTH PARTIES Accepted him as a judge" END Quote 2
So Adnani made Mubalaha with JN Shar3i Abu Abdullah al-Shami claiming that Sheikh Abu Abdullah lied against ISIS and that ISIS NEVER RAISED the matter to solve their expansion to Sheikh Aymen.
Just to clarify:
Sheikh Abu Abdullah said: both JN and ISIS asked Sheikh Aymen to judge between them (should ISI stay in Iraq and JN in Syria, or should JN join ISIS).
Adnani said: We never asked Sh Aymen to judge.
So let us see what Sheikh Abu Abdel Aziz al-Qatari said, the one Adnani himself gave tazkiyah to.
Here is what Sheikh Abu Abdel Aziz al-Qatari said:
"I WAS A WITNESS TO BOTH SHEIKH JAWLANI AND SHEIKH BAGHDADI, and both of them said WE WILL WAIT To hear FROM SHEIKH AYMEN (ha).
(I asked) Oh Sheikh Baghdadi, if the order came (from Sheikh Aymen) to return to what you were upon in the Islamic State of Iraq. Baghdadi said 'WE HEAR AND OBEY, I WILL RETURN, ME AND MY SOLDIERS TO WHAT WE WERE UPON! (ISI)'
(Sheikh al-Qatari then asked Sheikh Jawlani) Sheikh Jawlani, if the order came (from Sheikh Aymen) that you join the Islamic state of Iraq. (Sheikh Jawlani responded) 'I am a soldier from the soldiers of Islam"!! End Quote
Afterwards Sheikh Aymen judged in favor of JN and that's when Baghdadi went back against his promise and refused the order and broke away from AQ.
But back to the main point, who was lying in the mubahala?
Sheikh Abu Abdullah al-Shami or Adnani
You decide!